TL;DR - I miss Enclave, I'm canceling ESO and I miss Enclave.
At the risk of sounding desperate and perhaps a little whiny (pathetic), I've come to the conclusion that it may be impossible to achieve what we had in DAoC. I'm sure most of you came to that conclusion years ago, but I've held on for a bit longer. I believe this was because of how quickly and easily it came together back in 2001. It was the continued belief that because it happened so easily the first time, it was achievable a second time. It was almost effortless and I realized even back then (though maybe not right away) that it had little to do with anything I was doing. Hindsight naturally makes me wish I had made some different decisions.
Currently, I face canceling my Elder Scrolls Online subscription. Not because it's a bad game, far from it, but because I just can't seem to find people that I connect with. In fact, it feels like it's a complete waste of time to play an MMO if you don't have a group of people that you enjoy playing with.
ESO came close for me, as far as providing gameplay that I enjoyed in the same manner as DAoC. PvP wise you had grand campaigns at the start of the game that lasted 90 days in a huge awesome frontier. What you achieved, seemed to matter. Bonuses were provided to your entire faction (if they were in your campaign) that transferred over to PvE, much like in post-vanilla DAoC. There was a whisper of "pride" at the very most, but at least it was there. However, there are a few compromises that have been made by the developers. You can play for any realm/faction with an appropriate timer preventing you from joining the same campaign you were in with an opposite faction. Campaigns have become more and more fragmented with each game update. Recently they released their third content update which introduced campaigns lasting as little as 5 days. For me, it cheapens the experience. For others, I imagine this is a very casual and fun feature.
Previously, I felt like you could defend or siege a keep and feel like you've made an impact. However now it feels like nobody blinks an eye over any achievement in PvP other than becoming Emperor (I won't go into that either...which imo has created a mess in and of itself).
It forces me to think back to defending Bledmeer Faste in Odin's Gate. Preventing an enemy from taking that keep made you feel like you've just prevented an invasion. It was an intoxicating feeling, knowing that you had a chance to collapse their entire effort with one solid defense. Conversely, I can think of just as many defeats in an enemy frontier...
To anyone reading this, I'm sure this sounds a lot like "rose tinted glasses". There were challenges in DAoC and just outright frustrating elements.
Which brings me back to my point...
Enclave is what made DAoC great for me. In Midgard and Hibernia...(sorry surge!). Even the frustrations were mitigated by having cool people to play with.
Midgard was special and I took that for granted. Hibernia was special too and it turned into a bit of a love triangle! Ultimately, a lot of good people were in DAoC, even non-Enclave. I've often asked myself, what has changed? Is it just because we're older? some of you were my age when Enclave formed in DAoC so I'm convinced it's not necessarily an age thing. I could speculate on that topic for awhile so I'll just stop now.
Surge/Rerox's clever caption at the top left of this page is almost mocking me now. There is a piece of me that really does wish it was 2001. From a gaming perspective at least. I want to boot up my computer into Windows 2000 or Windows 98 SE, adjust my CRTs and slog around in DAoC waiting for a skald to log in to run me around.
I found a notebook that I used to write in when I was planning out things for the guild. It had everything from descriptions of guild ranks, lists of players and how to group them, crafting notes, people's e-mail addresses, a "kill" list of players I would look for etc...
I never led a relic raid for Midgard but I did for Hibernia so I even had keep taking strategies as well as siege numbers. It was embarrassing yet amusing to read through it (though let's be honest, it was mostly embarrassing...).
I've finally concluded, as I started to say at the beginning of this message, I likely won't see another Enclave in an MMO again. My attempts to revisit DAoC in its current form as well as Uthgard have convinced me of that further. Those experiences only succeeded in solidifying my convictions that I'm chasing the wind. Camelot Unchained may bring about some of what I'd like, but I'll believe that when I see it.
I hope there are still some of you that come back to read the forum for a bit of nostalgia now and then. I write this knowing that nobody may read it though I will continue under the assumption that everyone will!
I miss Enclave and to a lesser extent, I miss DAoC.
I will return in 4-6 months to re-post the same thing all over again I imagine when the nostalgia hits me.